|
INTRODUCTION
Next: ASSIGNING OBSERVING TIME
Up: WRITING A GOOD OBSERVING
Previous: WRITING A GOOD OBSERVING
For the observational astronomer, the importance of securing observing
time at world-class instruments cannot be overstated. It is fair to say
that scientific (and ultimately career) success or failure depends firstly
and solidly on quality of data. The ability to obtain telescope time is
sometimes even specified as a necessary qualification in job
advertisements. Given that this begins with the observing proposal, it is
surprising that so little has been written about this process. I found a
grand total of two papers which were even remotely related to writing a
good proposal - one directed at James Clerk Maxwell Telescope (JCMT)
users (Avery and MacLeod 1987) and some brief comments directed at Very
Large Array users (Bridle 1985). I suspect that this topic has been left
largely untouched because writing a good observing proposal requires
essentially two skills: the ability to generate good ideas, and the
ability to communicate those ideas to someone else. The former
falls into the realm of ``creativity", which is a rather nebulous concept
to most concrete-thinking,
goal-oriented scientists, and the latter is usually considered to be
someone else's job to teach. In this paper, I also will not attempt to
instruct about creative ideas or solid writing skills. However, anyone can make their proposal more convincing by ensuring that all
appropriate information is presented in a reasonably coherent fashion. It
is the purpose of this paper to assist in this process, firstly by
explaining how telescope time is allocated on the JCMT () and
secondly, by outlining some ways in which the proposal itself can be
improved ()Note: information is current as of Spring,
1994.. Although comments are directed, in the first instance, to
Canadian JCMT users, many will be generally applicable to any observing
proposal. Much of the information and ideas presented here were acquired
while serving a term with the Canadian Time Allocation Group (C-TAG) for
the JCMT. An earlier version of this paper specifically directed towards
graduate students can be found in the proceedings of the Third McMaster
Graduate Student Astronomy Workshop, Observing Techniques at
Millimetre and Submillimetre Wavelengths. If you cannot read through
this paper in its entirety, it may be worthwhile to look only at the Check List in .3.4.
Next: ASSIGNING OBSERVING TIME
Up: WRITING A GOOD OBSERVING
Previous: WRITING A GOOD OBSERVING
Henry Matthews@Thu Dec 22 09:43:40 HST 1994
|