Introduction - the new Annual Report
Introduction - the new Annual Report
At the May 2001 Board meeting, one of the decisions to help save
staff effort was to suspend the production of the normal `glossy bound'
Annual Report and replace it, on a trial basis, with a downloadable web-based
Report, which you find here. This Report contains links to the standard
`boilerplate' of the JCMT and its rules of operation that featured in previous
Reports. Science articles and more detailed descriptions of the facility
operations and development programmes for users will now be concentrated
in the expanded bi-annual Newsletters. This Report will predominately be
an audit of the year's operations and financial management.
Contents
Director's Note
Operations Review
Development Programme Review
Financial Data
Awards
of Telescope Time
Publications
Committee
Membership
JCMT
Facility Description
Director's Note
The JCMT reached a major milestone with 100 refereed publications
appearing in 2000. This is a fantastic achievement and a significant increase
on the publication output for the previous year. However, for the users
this was a very frustrating year, mainly due to the very poor weather conditions
that prevailed throughout much of the time. In spite of this, the completion
of some important SCUBA scan-mapping programmes represented another important
step forward in scientific delivery. Indeed, a report at the end of the
year for the citation index in the USA for late 1999 revealed two SCUBA
papers in the top-ten, an amazing demonstration of the huge impact this
instrument has made.
While the facility receivers were far from perfect, upgrades and refurbishments
continue to see improvements in performance and reliability. A major item
during the year for operations was the resignation of two further long-standing
Telescope System Specialists. This caused a major hiatus in the operations
during the recruitment process and in May the JCMT Board approved an experiment
of support astronomers undertaking the roles of TSS. This helped to minimise
the resulting loss of observing time through the restriction of some nights
to 12- rather than the normal 16-hour operation.
On the Development front, very good progress was made on ACSIS and HARP
and the future looks very positive with the latest developments on the
replacement instrument for SCUBA, SCUBA-2. The project plan for this was
finalised, with the UKATC being Prime Contractor and the next generation
monolithic detector arrays being produced by NIST (Boulder) and the University
of Edinburgh. The success of SCUBA-2 however had its downside for the JCMT
operations, with the Telescope Manager, Dr Wayne Holland resigning to take
up the post of Project Scientist for this exciting new instrument. This
caused yet another management reorganisation, and the Board approved the
appointment of an Associate Director, who would take over the tasks of
Telescope Manager including responsibility for all instrumentation. Dr
Per Friberg was appointed to this position. Progress continues to be slower
than hoped for on the link to the SMA, but the MOU should be agreed in
2001.
Overall this year could be seen as a transition year, between the operations
of the past, and plans for the future. In these, the facility will be more
tightly funded, and savings from general operations may be transferred
to support future development. However, these savings should not come at
the expense of facility reliability and the fault rate continued to cause
concern to the staff in Hawaii as well as the users and JCMT Board. A number
of meetings have served to focus on overcoming the problems, but staff
turnover and loss of `corporate memory' is undoubtedly making achieving
this more difficult. Focus on staff turnover continued to fail to find
a single cause for this, and indeed although staff turnover to other facilities
has been occurring, this is not an isolated problem for the JCMT.
One of the main underlying themes of the year was to consolidate the
project work and to ensure some of these long-standing operational projects
were completed. Attempting to undertake projects with the competing and
over-riding requirement for operations is always difficult, but a sharper
focus and reduced projects should enable the facility to make inroads on
a number of them in 2001. The Observation Management Project is a crucial
project for the support of queue-scheduled flexible observing and has been
dogged by lack of effort. However, this was revitalised late in the year
following the reorganisation of the JAC software and computing support.
The theme of 2001 will be to address the quality control of the instrumentation
and provide better tools for observers at the telescope and post-hoc for
data analysis.
Towards the end of the year, PPARC initiated a requirement that if the
UK should join ESO, it is likely that there needs to be significant savings
in the ground-based area. This means existing facilities and so the JCMT
was asked to come up with a draft savings plan for post-2005. With the
desired move to wide-field programmes following the delivery of HARP-B
and SCUBA-2, there is potential for savings post 2006. This also includes
the planned ability to undertake observing remotely from Hale Pohaku, without
the support of a TSS in order to maximise observing time for reduced cost.
Needless to say, this will be an area that is expected to continue to attract
significant management effort through 2001.
Science output continued to be exciting. SCUBA has become a tour do
force overall and two surveys showed the huge impact it has made. During
the latter part of 1999, two SCUBA papers were in the top-ten of all cited
papers in North America, a tremendous achievement. This was surpassed by
a recent study by Georges Meylan, STSci, which showed that in terms of
impact, SCUBA was second only to the HST, beating the Keck Observatory
and all other ground and space facilities, let alone any single instruments
(see table).
| Instrument |
Description |
# of Citations |
| Hubble Space Telescope |
Optical/UV; in space (NASA/ESA) |
415
|
| SCUBA |
Submillimeter; ground-based |
368
|
| ROSAT |
X-rays; in space (NASA) |
205
|
| Compton GRO |
Gamma Rays; in space (NASA) |
196
|
| Keck |
Optical; ground-based (CalTech and U.Calif.) |
180
|
| BeppoSax |
X-rays; in space (ESA/NASA) |
180
|
| SOHO |
Studies the Sun; in space (ESA/NASA) |
121
|
| CTIO 4 meter |
Optical; ground-based (US) |
110
|
| William Herschel Telescope |
Optical; ground-based (UK/The Netherlands) |
84
|
| Rossi XTE |
X-rays; in space (NASA) |
83
|
| Hipparcos |
Optical; in space (ESA) |
72
|
| ASCA |
X-rays; in space (Japan/NASA) |
68
|
| Palomar 200 inch |
Optical; ground-based (CalTech) |
65
|
| Kitt Peak Nat.O 4 meter |
Optical; ground-based (US) |
52
|
Amongst the highlights noted in 2000 were the completion of the SCUBA
850/450 map of the Galactic Centre regime by Pierce-Price et al. The truly
spectacular maps of the thermal dust continuum emission give an unbiased
picture of the temperature weighted column-density of material, and hence
enable the total masses of the molecular clouds to be derived and the details
of individual cloud structures to be investigated.
Large-scale SCUBA mapping was again the theme of D. Johnstone et al.,
who obtained a 700 square arcminute map of the star-forming complex Rho
Ophiuchi. The sensitivity and spatial resolution of the data allows for
an unprecedented analysis of the small scale, clumped structure with combined
dust and gas masses down to below one hundredth of a solar mass. With this
degree of precision, the process of star formation finally became directly
observable, revealing both the mass and the size of the clumps from which
the stars form. The Canadian Consortium for Star Formation led by George
Mitchell made spectacular inroads in their programme with a submillimetre
dust and gas analysis of the Orion B molecular cloud. An 800 square arcminute
SCUBA 850 map formed the basis for the study, onto which molecular gas
observations using RxB3 were added. Sixty-seven discrete continuum sources
were identified, with temperatures ranges from 20K to 80K. The gas-to-dust
ratio was found to vary substantially between the different sub-regions,
with CO freeze-out onto grains being apparent in some areas but not others,
the reason for which remains unexplained. A number of other exciting programmes
of star formation provided highlights for the September Newsletter.
Moving to more evolved objects, Greaves et al. obtained a SCUBA continuum
polarisation map of the Crab Nebula. This was taken using the scan-map
technique, one of the first uses of this method with the polarimeter. The
resulting map is indeed spectacular. The SCUBA data show the highest percentage
polarizations so far and may give the best high-resolution picture of the
magnetic field. The polarization is remarkably uniform across the main
part of the synchrotron-emitting nebula, running along the long axis of
the structure (the jet axis). However, a major deviation occurs where the
vectors appear to circle the cavity north-west of the bright core, confirming
a link between the physical and magnetic structures.
In the extragalactic field, the SCUBA deep-field observations continued
to be all the rage, with more detailed follow-up and more surveys at various
depths and sizes being commenced. Ivison and numerous colleagues undertook
SCUBA 850 imaging of high-redshift radio galaxies with SCUBA and serendipitous
detections were plentiful. Indeed, at one point it appeared that the rate
of detections seemed to far exceed those of blank-field surveys, and it
quickly became apparent that there might be an over-density of submm sources
in the fields of distant radio galaxies. Indeed, biased galaxy-formation
theories predict that massive galaxies at high redshifts should act as
?signposts? to high-density environments that subsequently evolve into
the cores of the richest clusters seen at the present day. These regions
are expected to be characterised by over-densities of young galaxies, probably
including a population of dusty, interaction-driven starbursts; the progenitors
of massive cluster ellipticals.
Therefore, it seems quite plausible that the mapping of high-redshift
AGN has revealed a population of clustered submm galaxies. Very deep 850
SCUBA searches were made in the fields of half-a-dozen radio galaxies and
quasars at z ~ 4, revealing an order-of-magnitude over-density of luminous
submm galaxies compared to typical fields. The likelihood of finding such
an over-density in random fields is <0.002. If the redshifts are the
same as the `signpost' galaxies then they have bolometric luminosities,
>1013 solar luminosities, which implies star-formation rates
consistent with those required to form a massive galaxy in a fraction of
a Gyr. Identifying these new SCUBA sources continues to prove tricky, requiring
extremely deep infrared and radio imaging. When all the data are combined,
the `photometric' redshifts plus some very red infrared objects strongly
suggests the redshifts are all greater than 2.8, and very probably the
same as the `target' AGN. This opens up a whole new area of study; the
link between density enhancements in the early Universe, clustering, AGN
activity and extremely heavily obscured dust emitting submillimetre galaxies.
Just for fun, SCUBA was also used to map the Moon during periods of
exceptionally wet atmospheric conditions in Director's Time. (It needs
to be so very wet to allow the horribly bright Moon not to saturate the
detectors even at lowest gain). A number of phases were mapped, including
a partial lunar eclipse. Craters and Maria are clearly revealed in the
images, and the comparison with the normal optical picture obtained from
reflected light becomes highly instructive regarding surface properties.
Operations Review
2000 was one of general frustration, both for the users and for
the staff. This has been for three main reasons: the water vapour content
above Mauna Kea has continued to be very poor, indeed one of the worst
years ever; the lack of TSSs due to resignations has resulted in some `blackout'
periods from the ensuing 12-hour nights; there have been failures of the
facility that were disappointing. On the other hand, the completion and
release into service of the new telescope control system (TCS) in August
and the completion of the active surface control electronics has been especially
welcomed and provided a boost to morale all-round.
The extended periods of poor weather eventually led to the introduction
of an upper-limit CSO tau value for observing with RxB3 and RxA3 in order
to reduce unnecessary additional work for support astronomers in obtaining
data for fallback programmes taken in very poor conditions.
The fault-loss continued to be unacceptably high and there have been
numerous meetings to focus on the causes and to attempt to eliminate them.
This was dominated by problems with instrumentation and major failures
of facility equipment, notably the secondary mirror unit that failed twice
(from unrelated causes).
A serious safety violation occurred at the JCMT in May, which had major
repercussions for the entire Observatory. The resulting investigation led
to the introduction of a new set of policies and procedures for TSSs and
those undertaking day-work, including a new certification process for TSSs.
SCUBA continues to dominate the applications for time and the resulting
allocations. The fixed-filter (850/450) mode continues after discussions
at the ITAC. SCUBA suffered two unplanned warm-ups that lost significant
time; the reason for one of these is known and procedures have been changed
to eliminate this particular risk. Noise performance has been generally
excellent and the release of the new calibration information is a real
highlight. Good work has been achieved with the polarimeter.
RxA3 was returned to service following its cryogenic failure and extensive
repair in early August and is working satisfactorily. The question of whether
to replace the mixer, which has a hump in the middle of the pass-band,
is being addressed. Following its overhaul by HIA early in the year, the
fault-loss for RxB3 has improved noticeably over the period, although there
is still some work to be done in getting this to be a very reliable and
work-horse receiver. Again, RxW continues to see little use. When it is
scheduled the weather is often poor, even for extended flexible blocks,
but good progress has been made on set-up using relative pointing from
RxB3. A new block-mode of allocating time on RxW will be tested for semester
01A.
The two holography receivers, RxH2 and RxH3 have both had problems due
to a variety of causes. Work on finally commissioning RxH3 has been delayed
due to, amongst other things, teething troubles with the new TCS. SPIFI
was totally wiped out by weather in May and there was only one night in
September (the last) when the weather was adequate for observing and on
that occasion the telescope secondary mirror unit failed! The Bonn receiver
was also wiped out by poor weather in May, and while the October run did
not do much better, but at least some good data were obtained.
Extensive pointing and tracking experiments have revealed some peculiarities
around transit that are still not understood, and work continues to track
down the problems. The effects are relatively stable and have been taken
out in software and so are transparent to users. The surface continues
to be in good shape.
Software support continues to be in short supply to solve problems and
complete on-going projects and this has been the subject of extensive internal
meetings. Excellent progress has been made on the Observatory Control System
(OCS) which is akin to the glue that links everything together and which
is critical (along with the delayed Observation Management Project) for
the arrival of ACSIS.
Following the resignation of the Telescope Manager and subsequent discussions
with staff, the Board supported the change of JCMT management by elimination
of the Telescope Manager post and subsuming most of the duties in an Associate
Director, Per Friberg. Since September, new staff duties have been agreed
and the management structure of the support astronomers revised, including
a SCUBA support group under Iain Coulson. The Director assumed direct responsibility
for overseeing the Development Fund to reduce some of the workload on Per
Friberg.
As a morale boosting exercise for support astronomers, encouragement
for research by conference participation and dissemination of new results
has been augmented by the award of $500 to all those who have an active
research programme. These funds have been provided by PPARC as part of
the ?In-house research? and it would be detrimental for morale not to allocate
these to Canadian or Netherlands researchers. The staffing turnover continues
to remain high, which seems to be a more prevalent feature for all the
observatories on Mauna Kea.
-
Mary Fuka, Senior Software Engineer, retired after a distinguished 11 years
of service at the JCMT, on May 4th.
-
The JCMT Telescope Manager, Wayne Holland, resigned on September 1st
to move to the UKATC as Project Scientist for SCUBA-2.
-
The Telescope Scheduler and TSS manager, Graeme Watt, resigned on September
15th, to take up a career role in PPARC headquarters, Swindon.
Graeme had been with the JCMT since its inception apart from a brief return
to Edinburgh in the mid- 1990?s.
-
Jeff Cox and Rusty Luthe resigned as JCMT TSSs in June and July respectively
after two decades of excellent service. Jeff moved to Gemini South and
Rusty moved to the CFHT.
-
Teresa Dorward (PPARC) left the JAC in October to move to La Palma as a
finance assistant and was replaced by Chelo Barreto Gomez (PPARC) who arrived
in October from La Palma.
-
Three new Telescope System Specialists were recruited: Scott Mikkelson
arrived on January 3rd, Jim Hoge arrived on May 15th
and Jonathan Kemp joined the JCMT on June 5th.
-
Nick Jessop joined the JCMT as a support astronomer from the University
of Lisbon on March 27th.
-
Kynan DeLorey joined the JAC at the beginning of June to work in the computer
group and Mathew Rippa was recruited as a junior software engineer on August
14th.
-
Ken Brown joined the JCMT on September 5th as a senior instrument
technician.
-
Tomas Chylek joined the JAC on September 18th as a senior mechanical
engineer.
-
Craig Walther joined the JAC on March 28th as the manager of
instrumentation and telescope software.
Staff attributed to the JCMT Shared Operations on March 31st
2001
(JAC indicates shared ~50/50 between JCMT and UKIRT)
| International RCUH (JCMT) |
| Ian Robson |
(JCMT and PPARC) |
Iain Coulson |
|
|
Elese Archibald |
| PPARC |
|
Donna DeLorm |
| Per Friberg |
(JCMT) |
Ken Brown |
| Ian Smith |
(JCMT) |
Firmin Oliveira |
| Tim Jenness |
(JAC) |
William Lundin |
| Wendy Light |
(JAC) |
James Hoge |
| Ian Midson |
(JAC) |
Thomas Lowe |
| Lindsay Marcer |
(JAC) |
Nick Jessop |
| Chelo Barreto |
(JAC) |
Robin Phillips |
| Tim Chuter |
(JAC) |
Brian Force |
| Frossie Economou |
(JAC) |
Neal Masuda |
| Jonathan Kemp |
| Netherlands (all JCMT) |
|
Peter Oshiro |
| Fred Baas |
| Remo Tilanus |
| RCUH (JAC) |
| Sidney Arakaki |
|
Junichi Meguro |
| Desiree Milar-Okinaka |
|
Felisa Teramoto |
| Vernon DeMattos |
|
Kevin O'Connell |
| David Fuselier |
|
Nick Rees |
| Velvet Gonsalves-Nases |
|
Ed Sison |
| Dean Shutt |
|
Henry Stilmack |
| Marjorie Dougherty |
|
Jay Tsutsumi |
| Sharlene Hamamoto |
|
Tomas Chylek |
| Mark Horita |
|
Mathew Rippa |
| Nash Kobayashi |
|
Craig Walther |
| Bernadette Leite |
|
Chris Yamasaki |
| Neil Oliveira |
|
Kynan DeLorey |
| Canada (all JCMT) |
| Henry Matthews |
| Gerald Moriarty-Schieven |
Development Programme Review
Good progress has been made on ACSIS although the Critical Design
Review (CDR) planned for June slipped to December. This was very successful,
although lack of a complete end-to-end system meant that it was not quite
at CDR. A major hold-up has been identified in the fabrication of the Down
Converter Modules and the IF. The project is now undergoing a major re-costing
and re-scheduling following CDR and it is now expected that delivery will
not take place until late spring or summer of 2002. However, apart from
the delay and cost over-run, the project is looking very good on the technical
side and should still be delivered well in time for HARP-B. A very positive
outcome of the ACSIS CDR was the focus on the software interfaces, which
involve a large number of groups and also impinges on the design of the
Observatory Control System and Observatory Management Project. The former
has now been incorporated fully into the ACSIS project at the UKATC and
the JAC.
HARP-B is making excellent progress and had a very successful Instrument
Design Review in November. The contract for SIS-device provision for HARP-B
was signed with DIMES earlier in the year but lack of progress on fabrication
of junctions after the move of the lab was becoming critical by the end
of the year. The project has reported a projected date for delivery of
July 2003. This is a slippage of four months and is the first registered
for this project.
Progress continues to be slow on the SMA project, understandably due
to their own pressure for completion deadlines. However, the fibres have
now been spliced and a revised project plan is under discussion with the
SMA in an effort to try and get some realistic planning into the project.
Excellent progress was made in Hawaii on working through the project
plan and costings for the new wide-field continuum camera, SCUBA-2. A major
and expensive part of this exercise was the contractual negotiations regarding
the production of the arrays by NIST. The contract provides carefully selected
break-points for withdrawal that minimise the degree of financial risk.
It was not possible to hold a CoDR for the proposed high-frequency heterodyne
camera, CHAMP-D, and this has been postponed until some time in the future.
The main facility project over the period, the Active Surface Control,
saw success in the `datuming' of the limit switches. This took place in
August and marked the completion of the electrical side of the project.
A major milestone for the JCMT was the successful commissioning of the
new TCS in late August. Initial niggling problems were quickly overcome
and it is now very reliable, offering the basis for efficiency improvements
downstream. On the other hand, extensive work by Nick Rees, who has shouldered
the responsibility and is personally responsible for the success of completing
the TCS, continues to reveal just how complex the interaction of the TCS
with the instrument control software has `grown' over the years. Firmin
Oliveira worked extensively on this project and deserves congratulations
and thanks.
Financial Data
The total available funds for JCMT operations for FY 2000/2001 were
$3,485,620 This was made up of the Board Allocation of $2,480,000 plus
carry-over from 1999/2000 of $27,369 plus other receipts of $978,251. The
Outturn figure was $3,259,278, a planned underspend of $226,342 due to
the wish to make savings from operations that can be transferred to development.
|
Top-level Operations Financial Summary FY2000/2001 ($)
|
| Board
Heading |
Board
Allocation |
Outturn |
Receipts |
Outturn
After
Receipts
|
Difference
From Board
Allocation
|
Diff
(%) |
| 1 (MK) |
480,000
|
521,482
|
|
521,482
|
41,482
|
8.6
|
| 2 (HP) |
140,000
|
85,510
|
|
85,510
|
-54,490
|
-38.9
|
| 3 (JAC) |
390,000
|
381,698
|
|
381,698
|
-8,302
|
-2.1
|
| 4 (Staff related) |
1,380,000
|
2,188,147
|
978,251
|
1,209,896
|
-170,104
|
-12.3
|
| 5 (IfA Fellow) |
70,000
|
63,553
|
|
63,553
|
- 6,447
|
-9.2
|
| 6 (IPMG) |
20,000
|
18,888
|
|
18,888
|
-1,112
|
-5.6
|
| Carry over |
27,369
|
|
|
|
-27,369
|
|
| Total |
2,507,369
|
3,259,278
|
|
2,281,027
|
-226,342
|
-9.0
|
Notes
Due to the renting of HP rooms by those facilities that had not purchased
rooms of their own, a significant income was obtained in this financial
year, which is the reason for the large underspend. This is not expected
to continue into FY01/02 as these facilities have now purchased rooms (four
from the JCMT). The staffing line shows a notable reduction as expected
due to planned savings through freezes on positions (two TSSs and one support
astronomer).
JCMT Internationally Shared Operations Budget: Outturn 00/01 details
Section 1. Mauna Kea $k Section 5. JCMT Fellowship $k
1.1 Utilities, Telephones 109.8 5.1 JCMT Fellowship 63.5
1.2 Telescope Maint 95.7 Sub-Total 5 63.5
1.3 Building Maint 32.5
1.4 Road Maint/snow clearing 29.5
1.5 Cryogens 187.6 Section 6. IPMG Support
-
Receiver Maintenance 34.0
1.7 Computer Systems 13.7 6.1 Scientific Admin. Travel 18.9
1.8 Remote Operations Project 18.7 Sub-Total 6. 18.9
Sub-Total 1 521.5
Section 2. Mid Level Facility GRAND TOTAL:$3,259.3k
-
HP Costs 69.6
-
Visitors Centre, Emerg Serv 15.9
Sub-Total 2 85.5
Section 3. Sea level facility
-
Office Equipment 22.6
-
Hilo Telecomms/utilities 82.0
-
Administration 1.8
3.1.6 Publicity 8.3
3.1.7 Safety and First Aid 13.5
-
Lab and Handling Equipment 11.2
-
Library 11.4
3.1.12 Building Maintenance 40.6
3.2 Vehicle Proc and Maint 68.9
-
Computer Systems 73.5
-
Computer Communications 20.1
-
Instrument Projects 23.2
-
Observing Management Project 4.6
Sub-Total 3 381.7
Section 4. Staff costs
4.2 RCUH Staff & Recruit 1,962.0 (gross)
4.2.1 Director 133.5 (gross)
-
Cons/Travel/Conf/Training 92.6
Sub-Total 4 2,188.1
JCMT Development Fund Outturn summary FY 2000/01
Current Projects Contractors Outturn 2000/01
($k)
RxA3 upgrade HIA -12.6(1)
SIS Junctions DIMES 63.3
Optics Design Maynooth 7.3
SCUBA 2 UKATC 585.2(2)
SCUBA 2 JAC 14.1(3)
Active surface control project JAC 4.6
RxH3 JAC 4.4
ACSIS HIA 0 (3)
ACSIS UKATC 18.2
ACSIS JAC 24.5
RFTM JAC 5.1
OCS UKATC 26.3
HARP-B MRAO 65.6
HARP-B UKATC 60.5
HARP-B HIA 27.5
HARP-B JAC 0
Instrument Programme Travel JAC 7.3
TOTAL 901.4
(1) Repaid from previous `float'.
(2) Includes staff effort of 2.8 dsy at £54 each charged
to the Development Fund under the
new rules applied to SCUBA-2.
(3) Invoice received for $25.046k but HIA already have a
previous `float' of $30.224k.
|