Newsletter issue 11
UNITED KINGDOM INFRARED TELESCOPE
Newsletter
Issue 11, September 2002
Near-Infrared Imaging of the Counterparts of QSO Metal Absorption Line Systems
Toru Misawa1, Nobunari Kashikawa2, Youichi Ohyama2,
and Masanori Iye2,3.
1University of Tokyo, Japan
2National Astronomical observatory, Japan
3The Graduate University for Advanced Studies, Japan
Pair (Triple) quasars separated by a few arcmin on the
sky sometimes have common metal absorption lines at almost the same
redshift ([1],[2],[3]). This implies the existence of intervening
absorbers clustering at the redshift. In fact, several galaxies have
been detected as counterparts of absorption lines around quasars at
the redshifts identical to those of absorption lines
([4],[5],[6],[7]).
The quasar triplet (KP76/KP77/KP78) is located on the sky within a
small FOV of 3 arcmin ([3]). All of them have C IV absorption line
complexes at z=2.24 in their spectra ([8]). The radial velocity
separations of these absorption lines are within 1600 km/s of each
other. The linear angular distance on the sky between these systems at
z=2.24 corresponds to ~1 Mpc (Omega0=1, H0 = 75
km/s/Mpc), which is too large for a single absorber to intercept all
three lines of sight. Such common absorption lines are plausibly
produced by gas clouds associated with galaxies that constitute a
cluster (group) of galaxies at z=2.24
Figure 1 : K98 and 2.122(S1) images of the field around KP78. The
quasar and the two candidates for star forming galaxies at z=2.24 are
marked with circles. The size of the field is 90" x 90", which
corresponds to 480kpc x 480kpc (Omega0 = 1,
H0 = 75 km/s/Mpc).
Based on this assumption, we carried out a deep imaging observation of
the field around one of the quasar triplet (KP78) with UKIRT + UFTI on
May 24 - 25, 2002. We used the K98 filter as a broad-band, and the
narrow-band 2.122(S1) filter which covers the H-alpha emission lines
of the galaxies at z=2.24. With effective exposure times of 3.3h
for K98, and 9.25h for 2.122(S1), we acquired the wonderful images in
Figure 1 to depths of 20.9 mag for K98 and 20.0 mag for 2.122(S1),
with S/N=5.
Figure 2 : 2.122(S1) magnitude versus K98 - 2.122(S1) colour
diagram. The filled stars denote objects that are detected in the
2.122(S1) images, while the thin dots represent the artificial
galaxies for comparison. The obj1 and obj2 are candidates for the star
forming galaxies at z=2.24.
Figure 2 is the color-magnitude diagram for the comparison of detected
objects with artificial ones. For the color excess analysis to isolate
H-alpha emitting objects, accurate evaluation of the photometric
errors is necessary. We have created about 25,000 artificial galaxies
on the observed images. A pair of dashed, dash-dotted, and dotted
lines in Figure 2 indicate the 1-sigma, 2-sigma and 3-sigma
distributions of artificial galaxies, respectively. Two objects were
found to be deviated beyond the 3-sigma level. We could not detect
them in the K98 image even with S/N=2, but they are evident in the
2.122(S1) image, which suggests that they have very strong line fluxes
compared with continuum fluxes.
If they are attributed to H-alpha emission lines on the band-pass of
the 2.122(S1), we can estimate the lower limits of their star
formation rates to be >125, and >54 Mo per year for obj1 and obj2,
respectively. The colour excess, however, could be caused not by
H-alpha but by Ly-alpha, [OII], [OIII], or other lines
([9],[10]). Spectroscopic follow-up observation is clearly required
for further discussion.
If we confirm that our technique is useful for finding clusters
(groups) of galaxies at high redshift, we will apply it to the fields
around other quasar pair (triplet). UIST with its wide FOV (120" x
120") can be expected to play an important role for the achievement of
our purpose.
References
[1] Shaver, Boksenberg, and Robertson, 1982,ApJ,261,7
[2] Jakobsen et al., 1986,ApJ,303,27
[3] Crotts & Fang, 1998,ApJ,502,16
[4] Bergeron & Boisse, 1991,A&A,243,344
[5] Lanzetta et al., 1998,astro-ph/9812272
[6] Chen, Lanzetta, and Webb, 2001,ApJ,556,158
[7] Chen et al., 2001,ApJ,559,654
[8] Crotts, Burles, and Tytler, 1997,ApJ,489,L7
[9] Teplitz, Malkan, and McLean, 1999,ApJ,514,33
[10] Teplitz et al., 2000,ApJ,542,18
Disks around Young Brown Dwarfs
Michael C. Liu
Institute for Astronomy, University of Hawaii
While the number of known brown dwarfs is growing rapidly, the origin of
these objects is an unanswered question. One insight into the formation
mechanism(s) for brown dwarfs is whether young substellar objects
possess circumstellar disks. There is abundant observational evidence
and theoretical expectation for accretion disks around young solar-type
stars. Thus, the presence of disks around young brown dwarfs would be
naturally accommodated in ``star-like'' formation scenarios. On the
other hand, scenarios involving dynamical interactions (e.g., collisions
and/or ejections) are likely to be hostile to circumstellar disks.
In collaboration with Joan Najita of NOAO and Alan Tokunaga of the
University of Hawaii, I have recently completed a large L'-band (3.8
micron) survey for disks around young brown dwarfs and very low mass
stars using IRCAM/TUFTI on UKIRT (Liu, Najita, & Tokunaga 2002, ApJ, in
press). Brown dwarf disks can be readily identified by excess L'-band
emission, which arises from warm material within a few stellar radii
(<0.1 AU). In addition, our survey is sensitive enough to detect young
brown dwarf photospheres, and hence the absence of a disk can be
discerned --- therefore we can determine the frequency of disks around
brown dwarfs for the first time. Our sample comprises nearly all the
known sources in the Taurus and IC 348 star-forming regions which have
been spectroscopically classified to be very cool, with masses of
~15 to ~100 MJup based on current models. (At ages of
a few Myr, young brown dwarfs have spectral types of mid to late-M. As
they age and consequently cool, they will become the L and T-type
objects found in the field.)
Figure 1: Dereddened (Ks - L') colors (2.0-4.1 micron) as a
function of spectral type for our sample of young brown dwarfs and very
low mass stars. Approximate mass estimates are listed at the top. The
heavy line represents the colors of field M dwarfs. Most of our targets
show intrinsic IR emission in excess of that expected from their bare
photospheres.
Figure 1 shows that most objects in our sample have intrinsic colors
which are redder than expected from their bare photospheres, i.e., they
possess IR excesses. Also, the lower envelope of the observed color
distribution agrees well with the heavy line, indicating that field M
dwarfs provide a legitimate comparison. Like the case for T Tauri
stars, such IR excesses are naturally explained by circumstellar disks;
non-disk (e.g. spherical) configurations of dust which could produce the
IR excesses would lead to very high line-of-sight extinctions, which is
not observed.
The disk frequency in our sample appears to be independent of mass;
however, some objects, including the very coolest (lowest mass) ones,
lack IR excesses. Disks around young brown dwarfs and very low mass
stars appear to be very common --- we find an excess frequency of
~75% for the sample as a whole. This disk fraction is
comparable to the disk fraction observed for young stars in the same
regions.
For T Tauri stars, both the optical line emission and the IR excesses
are believed to originate from disk accretion. The IR excesses come
from warm dust grains in the disk, while H-alpha emission arises from
accretion of disk material onto the central star, e.g., via a boundary
layer or a magnetically regulated accretion flow. Therefore, the
H-alpha emission and IR excesses should be correlated, and indeed such
a correlation is seen among T Tauri stars (e.g., Kenyon & Hartmann 1995,
ApJS, 101, 117). Figure 2 shows a comparison for our sample of young
brown dwarfs and very low mass stars, using H-alpha data from the
literature. A 3-sigma correlation is observed between the intrinsic
(Ks - L') excess and H-apha emission, based on the Spearman rank
correlation coefficient. This level of correlation is comparable to
that observed for T Tauri stars and provides strong circumstantial
evidence for accretion disks around young brown dwarfs. Furthermore,
the mere existence of accreting brown dwarfs at ages of a few Myr argues
for mass-dependent accretion rates, since brown dwarfs with typical
T Tauri star accretion rates would not remain substellar.
Figure 2: Comparison of the intrinsic (Ks - L') excesses and
H-alpha equivalent width in Angstroms for most of our sample. The two
quantities are well-correlated, supporting the idea that the optical and
near-IR emission both originate from the same phenomenon, namely
circum(sub)stellar accretion disks.
Altogether, we find that (1) disks around brown dwarfs are common, and
(2) brown dwarf disks are contemporaneous with disks around T Tauri
stars. The latter shows that brown dwarf disks are at least as
long-lived as disks around stars, assuming that the stars and brown
dwarfs are roughly coeval. These observations are naturally
accommodated in a picture where brown dwarfs form in a similar manner as
stars --- our results offer prima facie evidence for a common origin for
objects from the stellar regime down to the substellar and
planetary-mass regime.
Alternative formation scenarios, such as disk-disk collisions and/or
premature ejection, involve dynamical interactions in creating brown
dwarfs. While specific predictions are lacking due to the stochastic
nature of these scenarios, brown dwarfs formed by these mechanisms are
generally expected to have smaller and less massive disks, and
consequently shorter disk lifetimes, compared to brown dwarfs formed in
isolation. This expectation conflicts with our finding that brown dwarf
disks are at least as long-lived as disks around young stars.
Further studies will be important for determining the properties of
brown dwarf disks, and also for placing these objects in context with
our physical understanding of the star formation process. Finally, the
very high disk fraction of young brown dwarfs raises the possibility of
forming planets around brown dwarfs. Such planetary systems would
represent an fascinating alternative to the numerous planetary systems
found around solar-type stars.
An UFTI
K-band study of the counterparts to the ISO-FIRBACK 170 micron population.
Scott C. Chapman and George Helou
California Institute of Technology, Pasadena, CA 91125
The spectral shape of the far-infrared background (FIRB) detected by
FIRAS at 140 and 240 micron (Puget et al. 1996; Fixsen et
al. 1998) indicates a peak at ~200 micron with energy comparable to
the optical/UV background. This peak arises from optical/UV radiation
from star formation and AGN activity in obscured galaxies at z >> 0
which is absorbed by dust and reradiated in the far-infrared. This
obscured population of galaxies could host approximately half of the
massive star formation activity over the history of the Universe (e.g.
Blain et al. 1999).
Far-infrared surveys at wavelengths close to the peak of the FIRB
provide a powerful route for understanding the properties of the
obscured activity in the distant Universe and its relevance to the
formation and evolution of both galaxies and super-massive black
holes. The FIRBACK (Far-InfraRed BACKground)
survey obtained wide-field imaging at 170 micron with the PHOT instrument
on-board ISO satellite in three separate regions of the sky
chosen for low Galactic cirrus foreground. FIRBACK is the most
reliable and deepest (\sigma(170 micron) ~ 40 mJy) infrared census at
wavelengths near the peak in the FIRB. The FIRBACK sources down to
120 mJy account for about 10% of the FIRB seen by COBE at
140-240 micron (Puget et al. 1996). Evolutionary models
(e.g. Dole et al. 2001) suggest that
the sources identified by FIRBACK comprise both star-forming galaxies
at low redshifts, z ~ 0.1, and a population of much more luminous
galaxies at higher redshifts. The models predict that a
quarter of the FIRBACK sources should have z > 0.5, with a tail
reaching beyond z=1.5. The sources in this high-redshift tail
provides the strongest constraints on the evolution of the population
contributing to the peak of the FIRB at ~200 micron. For this reason
the identification and study of these galaxies is of particular interest.
The coarse beam of ISO at 170 micron produces large uncertainties
in the source positions, (100 arcsec diameter, 99% error
circle). However, using the empirical radio-infrared correlation for
star forming galaxies (Helou et al. 1985), we can exploit deep 1.4-GHz
radio data from the VLA in C-array configuration (Ciliegi et al. 1999)
to identify the FIRBACK sources with positional uncertainties of only
~1" (15" VLA beamsize). We can also identify counterparts using
shorter wavelength observations which are expected to correlate with
the 170 micron emission, such as the ISOCAM 15 micron maps over the
same region of sky.
A large fraction of the proposed radio and mid-IR counterparts to the
FIRBACK galaxies are not detected in shallow sky surveys in the
optical (DPOSS2) or near-IR (2MASS). We have thus undertaken a K-band
survey with the UFTI camera on UKIRT with the purpose of identifying
the faint and red galaxy counterparts to the FIRBACK sources. We have
also taken advantage of the superb seeing afforded by
UKIRT to study the morphologies of some of the
brighter and more nearby galaxy identifications to the FIRBACK
population.
|
|
Figure 1: A montage of 30"x30" cutouts of our UKIRT K-band
imagery of the FIRBACK population. The radio or ISOCAM
identification is always centered in the frame. The lower
S/N detections have been smoothed with the PSF. Sources
are brightest at K to faintest (left to right) FN1-4, 24,
45, 44, 8, 68, 13, 42, 64, 78, 40, 48, 111, 117, 34, 32,
and 59.
|
Here we provide a snapshot view (Figure 1) of our complete UKIRT
observations, presented
in a K-magnitude sequence from brightest to faintest, outlining the diversity
in FIRBACK galaxy counterparts seen in the optical (all sources fall into a
narrow range of 170 micron fluxes from 140-300 mJy).
All panels show a 30" by 30" K-band image, where contours are used to
highlight the structure of the brighter sources, while the faintest
sources have been smoothed with the PSF for display purposes.
An accompanying spectroscopic analysis based on Palomar 5-m observations
of many of these galaxies will appear in a forthcoming paper.
Bright nearby spiral and elliptical galaxies form the brightest members of
our sample. The best fit dust temperatures of ~20 K suggest that
FIRBACK has selected galaxies similar in properties to the Milky Way,
although often with significantly higher bolometric luminosities likely
related to higher rates of ongoing star formation. Fine detail of the
spiral and bar structures can be discerned with the superb
~0.4 arcsec UKIRT images.
Fainter galaxies appear resolved relative to a stellar PSF, but often
do not reveal much more than a single near-IR component, detected at
only ~5-10 \sigma and barely resolved, with red colors relative to the
optical bands (where they are often undetected to R ~ 24). All targets
attempted were detected with UKIRT, suggesting that the FIRBACK
population with radio identifications are completely detected to K=21.
Spectroscopic followup to these faint red galaxies is extremely
difficult, even with 10m telescopes, and only three members of this
class currently have robust redshift identifications. Two of these
FIRBACK galaxies (FN1-40 and FN1-64) observed in our UKIRT program
have already been presented in an ApJ paper (Chapman et al. 2002). The
near-IR observations identified extremely red counterparts to both
galaxies, and revealed complex merger morphologies, contrasting the
more isolated examples in the greater sample. When available, the
redshifts suggest that the dust temperatures are lower than expected
for such luminous galaxies, by comparison to local ultra-luminous
examples.
Ongoing study of this galaxy population will provide the first glimpse of
the new classes of galaxies to be discovered with the SIRTF satellite,
scheduled for launch January 2003. SIRTF will map large regions of the sky
over similar wavelength bands to ISO, but at much greater sensitivities.
References:
Blain, A. W., Smail, I., Ivison, R. J., \& Kneib, J.-P. 1999,
MNRAS, 302, 632
Chapman, S., Smail, I., Ivison, R., Helou, G., Dale, D., Lagache, G.,
2002, ApJ, 573, 66
Ciliegi, P., et al., 1999, MNRAS, 302, 222
Dole, H. et al. 2001, ApJ, 591, 345
Fixsen, D. J., Dwek, E., Mather, J. C., Bennett, C. L.,
\& Shafer, R. A. 1998, ApJ, 508, 123
Helou, P., et al., 1985, ApJ 440, 35
Puget, J.-L., Abergel, A., Bernard, J.-P., Boulanger, F.,
Burton, W. B., Desert, F.-X., \& Hartmann, D. 1996, A\&A, 308, L5
Galaxy Cannibalism as seen by UKIRT and HST
Marc Seigar
Joint Astronomy Centre, Hilo.
The image below shows a combination of an UFTI K-band image with a
HST/WFPC2 F814W I band image of the brightest cluster galaxy in Abell 193.
The UFTI image revealed 3 nuclei in this galaxy for the first time (Seigar
et al. 2002, in prep.), demonstrating the excellent spatial resolution
available with UKIRT (FWHM~0.35"). This is only a factor of ~2 worse than
the resolution capabilities of HST in the I band (as measured from the
F814W image, although this is not the diffraction limit of HST due to
undersampling of the psf with WFPC2).
Figure 1 - UFTI and HST imaging of the brightest cluster
galaxy in
Abell 193, showing the triple nucleus system revealed by
UFTI.
Previously this galaxy was only believed to have a double nucleus (e.g.
Hoessel et al. 1985, AJ, 90, 1648). Galaxies such as this one are thought
to be constantly growing at the centres of clusters as they "cannibalize"
their less massive neighbours (Hausman & Ostriker 1978, ApJ, 224, 300). As
a result multiple nuclei are seen in approximately 50% of brightest
cluster galaxies. In this galaxy (IC 1695) the resulting I-K colours of
the nuclei (from north to south) are 1.74, 1.35, and 1.57 respectively,
demonstrating that, if the cannibalism hypothesis is true, a merger
has taken place in its recent history.
UNITED KINGDOM INFRARED TELESCOPE
Newsletter
Issue 11, September 2002
|