Newsletter issue 16
UNITED KINGDOM INFRARED TELESCOPE
Newsletter
Issue 16, Spring 2005
Are Passive Spiral Galaxies truly "passive" and "spiral"? : a
Near-Infrared perspective
Chisato Yamauchi1,2 and Tomotsugu Goto3
1Department of Physics and Astrophysics, Nagoya
University, Chikusa-ku, Nagoya 464-8602, Japan
2National Astronomical Observatory, 2-21-1 Osawa, Mitaka,
Tokyo 181-8588, Japan
3Department of Physics and Astronomy, The Johns Hopkins
University, 3400 North Charles Street, Baltimore, MD 21218-2686, USA
Passive spiral galaxies - unusual galaxies with spiral morphologies but
without any sign of on-going star formation - have recently been
shown to exist preferentially in cluster infalling regions. This
discovery directly connects passive spiral galaxies to cluster
galaxy evolution studies, such as the Butcher-Oemler effect or the
morphology-density relation. Thus, detailed study of passive spiral
galaxies could potentially yield new insight on the underlying physical
mechanisms governing cluster galaxy evolution.
However, in previous work, passive spiral galaxies were selected from
low-resolution optical images with ~1.5 arcsec seeing. Passive spirals
could therefore be mis-identified as S0 galaxies, or as
dusty-starburst galaxies which are not passive at all. To address this
issue we performed deep, high-resolution, near-infrared imaging of
32 passive spiral galaxies with UKIRT.
We selected our target galaxies from 73 passive spiral galaxies
presented by Goto et al. (2003). None of the 73 galaxies have any
emission in [OII] or H&alpha (< 1&sigma in equivalent width) though
all have a disc-like morphology. Of the 73 passive spiral galaxies,
the 32 targets accessible during our run in September 2003 were
observed in the K band using the UKIRT Fast Track Imager (UFTI). Data
were taken during periods of good atmospheric transparency and with
excellent seeing of ~0.5 arcsec. In Figure 1, we show K-band images of
16 of the 32 passive spiral galaxies. Although selected in poorer
conditions, the deep and high resolution imaging capability of UKIRT
clearly shows the discs and spiral arm structures. Thus, passive
spiral galaxies are not S0s, but truly are spiral galaxies.
|
|
FIGURE 1:
UKIRT K band images of passive spiral
galaxies. Each image is 35x35 arcsec in size.
|
We used the restframe optical-infrared (r-K) colour distribution for
the observed passive spiral galaxies to investigate whether they are dusty
starburst galaxies or truly passive galaxies. Since the K band is less
affected by dust extinction than the r band, dusty starburst galaxies are
known to have redder colours in r-K by ~1 mag (Smail et al. 1999). Figure
2 plots g-i colour against r-K colour. Optical photometry (g, r, and i)
is from the SDSS. The black circles are for passive spiral galaxies
observed with UKIRT. The red squares are for early-type galaxies in the
control sample. For a reference, we plot the distribution of all galaxies
in the volume limited sample with K magnitudes measured with the Two
Micron All Sky Survey (2MASS; Jarrett et al. 2000) as the contour.
|
|
FIGURE 2:
Restframe g-i vs. r-K two-colour diagram. The circles are for
passive spirals. The squares are for the early-type galaxies in the
control sample. The contours represent all galaxies in the volume limited
sample with 2MASS K magnitudes.
|
Interestingly, compared with all galaxies (the contour), passive spiral
galaxies (circles) are not redder in r-K colour. Indeed, the r-K
colours of the passive spiral galaxies are indistinguishable from the early-type
galaxies (squares). These results support the truly passive nature of these
galaxies, since dusty starburst galaxies should have r-K colours redder by 1
magnitude than normal galaxies.
Thus, our results support the truly "passive" and "spiral" nature of these
galaxies. It is very likely that passive spiral galaxies are indeed
transition objects currently undergoing cluster galaxy evolution. Further
studies of passive spiral galaxies will reveal the physical mechanisms
governing cluster galaxy evolution.
References
Goto T., Okamura S., Sekiguchi, M., et al. 2003, PASJ, 55, 757
Jarrett T. H., Chester T., Cutri R., Schneider S., Skrutskie M., Huchra J.
P., 2000, AJ, 119, 2498
Smail I., Morrison G., Gray M. E., Owen F. N., Ivison R. J., Kneib J.-P.,
Ellis R. S., 1999, ApJ, 525, 609
High precision K-band photometry of the transiting exoplanet
HD209458b
Ignas Snellen
Leiden Observatory, The Netherlands
The first direct detection of an extrasolar
planet will constitute a true milestone in astronomy. Although now
more than 130 planets have been discovered indirectly, the star/planet
contrasts have so far proven to be too high to reach this goal. Most
attempts have concentrated on probing star-light reflected from the
atmospheres of hot Jupiters using optical echelle spectroscopy. This
can in principle be disentangled from direct star light by its slowly
varying Doppler shift over the orbital period of the planet. Contrasts
down to 10-4-5 have been reached, but these have proven to
be insufficient to detect reflected light from even the most promising
candidates (e.g. Leigh et al. 2003).
For a few years it has been known that the
orientation of the orbit of the hot Jupiter HD209458b is such that it
transits its host star (Charbonneau et al. 2000). This can be of
great benefit when trying to detect direct emission from this planet,
since it implies that the planet will be eclipsed by the star on
regular intervals. Instead of trying to disentangle a planetary
component which only varies slowly over a several day period, in this
case the light from the planet completely disappears within 26 minutes
of the ingress time, to be blocked off by the host star for 2.2 hours,
after which time it reappears again. At optical wavelengths, the depth
of the secondary eclipse is expected to be at the 10-5
level, beyond the reach of current instrumentation. However, in the
near- and mid-infrared the contrast is significantly better. Here the
contribution from the planet is dominated by its thermal emission,
resulting in an eclipse depth of perhaps as much as a few
milli-magnitude in the K-band.
|
FIGURE 1: During a transit (T1 -- T3) a small fraction
of the star's light is blocked off by the planet,
allowing the determination of its size. The secondary
eclipse (S1 - S3) is the moment the planet moves behind
the host star. The small decrement is due to the missing
light contribution from the planet.
|
Using spectroscopy, Richardson et al. (2003) have tried to detect the
disappearance and reappearance of planetary absorption features around
the secondary eclipse, though without success. Here we report on a different
approach, using high precision K-band photometry with UIST. This
project is highly challenging! To be able to detect the planetary
signal of HD209458b a precision of ~0.5 milli-magnitude per hour needs
to be achieved; normally, the accuracy of near-infrared photometry is
limited to the 1% level. In addition, the target is of K=6.3,
and therefore can only be observed - without saturating the array - by
defocusing the telescope. The target and two nearby reference stars
were observed in cycles of 15 minutes, each observation consisting of
a repeated 5-point jitter, with the target and the reference stars
falling onto the same area of the array.
The first test observations
were taken in July 2004. After careful flat fielding and sky
subtraction two clear patterns emerged. Firstly, a dependence of the
measured flux on the position in the jitter sequence. This is most
likely caused by a residual dark current effect. The second is a
dependence of the measured flux on the width of the star profile. This
is probably caused by a combination of a residual non-linearity and an
aperture effect. Both effects can be calibrated in an ad-hoc manner,
resulting in a 1&sigma scatter of 4.0 milli-magnitude per jitter
point, and a ~1-1.5 milli-magnitude uncertainty per 15 minute cycle.
Two secondary eclipses of HD209458b were subsequently observed on
23 August 2004 and 13 September 2004. The preliminary photometry of
the first epoch is shown in Figure 2. Although this formally shows a
~3&sigma detection, we are too uncertain about possible slowly varying
systematic effects during the 4 hour observation, so we do not claim
this as a detection. In addition, the second epoch observation suffers
from a sharp change in seeing, complicating the analysis and thereby
not allowing a confirmation (Snellen 2005, in prep.).
|
FIGURE 2: Preliminary result of the K-band photometry of
HD209458 (blue crosses) and the two reference stars (red
diamonds and squares) during the secondary eclipse of
August 23, 2004. The data are corrected for
non-linearity, aperture effects, and change in airmass.
The lower panel shows the relative photometry of HD209458. Although a
tentative signal is observed, at the present time we are too uncertain
about systematic effects to claim this as a detection (Snellen 2005,
in prep.).
|
However, these first observations are promising, and indicate that in
the near future a genuine planet signal may be detected using this
method. Further developments in observing strategy, to improve the
photometry on HD209458b or even more suitable transiting exoplanets,
are underway.
References
Charbonneau et al. 2000, ApJ, 529, 45
Leigh et al. 2003, MNRAS, 346, L16
Richardson et al. 2003, ApJ, 597, 581
UNITED KINGDOM INFRARED TELESCOPE
Newsletter
Issue 16, Spring 2005
|